Card #	Player name	Team	Comment
1	Mickey Mantle	NY-A
2	Dick Groat	StL-N
3	Steve Barber	Bal-A
4	Ken McBride	LA-A
5	Warren Spahn	Mil-N
6	Bob Friend	Pit-N
7	Harmon Killebrew	Min-A
8	Dick Farrell	Hou-N
9	Hank Aaron	Mil-N
10	Rich Rollins	Min-A
11	Jim Gentile	KC-A
12	Willie Mays	SF-N
13	Camilo Pascual	Min-A
14	Roberto Clemente	Pit-N
15	Johnny Callison	Phi-N
16	Carl Yastrzemski	Bos-A
17	Billy Williams	Chi-N
18	Johnny Romano	Cle-A
19	Jim Maloney	Cin-N
20	Norm Cash	Det-A
21	Willie McCovey	SF-N
22	Jim Fregosi	LA-A
23	George Altman	NY-N
24	Floyd Robinson	Chi-A
25	Chuck Hinton	Was-A
26	Ron Hunt	NY-N
27	Gary Peters	Chi-A
28	Dick Ellsworth	Chi-N
29	Elston Howard	NY-A
30	Brooks Robinson	Bal-A
31	Frank Robinson	Bal-A
32	Sandy Koufax	LA-N
33	Rocky Colavito	KC-A
34	Al Kaline	Det-A
35	Ken Boyer	StL-N
36	Tommy Davis	LA-N