| Card no. | Player | Year | Set name | |
| 409-1 | Orator Shaffer | 1887-1890 | Old Judge N172 | Scan |
| 409-2 | Orator Shaffer | 1887-1890 | Old Judge N172 | Scan |
| 409-3 | Orator Shaffer | 1887-1890 | Old Judge N172 | Scan |
| 409-4 | Orator Shaffer | 1887-1890 | Old Judge N172 | Scan |
| 409-5 | Orator Shaffer | 1887-1890 | Old Judge N172 | Scan |
