| Card no. | Player | Year | Set name | |
| 20 | Keith McDonald | 1994 | Classic Best Johnson City Cardinals | Scan |
| 3706 | Keith McDonald | 1994 | Fleer/ProCards Johnson City Cardinals | Scan |
| 18 | Keith McDonald | 1996 | Best St. Petersburg Cardinals | |
| 12 | Keith McDonald | 1997 | Best Arkansas Travelers | |
| NNO (11) | Keith McDonald | 1998 | Grandstand Memphis Redbirds | |
| 72 | Keith McDonald | 2000 | Bowman Draft Picks and Prospects | |
| 72 | Keith McDonald | 2000 | Bowman Draft Picks and Prospects Chrome | |
| 80 | Keith McDonald | 2000 | Fleer Tradition Update | |
| 124 | Keith McDonald | 2000 | Fleer Showcase | |
| 124 | Keith McDonald | 2000 | Fleer Showcase Legacy Collection | |
| 124 | Keith McDonald | 2000 | Fleer Showcase Masterpiece | |
| 124 | Keith McDonald | 2000 | Fleer Showcase Prospect Showcase First | |
| 3 | Keith McDonald | 2000 | Memphis Redbirds Team Issue | Scan |
| 29 | Keith McDonald | 2000 | Memphis Redbirds Team Issue | Scan |
| 373 | Keith McDonald | 2001 | Fleer Tradition | |
| 130 | Keith McDonald | 2001 | Fleer E-X | |
| 290 | Keith McDonald | 2001 | Fleer Triple Crown | |
| 492 | Keith McDonald | 2001 | Pacific | |
| 239 | Keith McDonald | 2001 | Fleer Ultra | |
| 239 | Keith McDonald | 2001 | Fleer Ultra Gold Medallions | |
| 239 | Keith McDonald | 2001 | Fleer Ultra Platinum Medallions | |
| 16 | Keith McDonald | 2001 | Memphis Redbirds Team Issue | Scan |
| 86 | Keith McDonald | 2002 | Topps Total | |
| 600 | Keith McDonald | 2002 | Upper Deck 40 Man | |
| 4 | Keith McDonald | 2002 | Memphis Redbirds Team Issue | Scan |
