| Card no. | Player | Year | Set name | |
| 301-1-1 | Tommy McCarthy | 1887-1890 | Old Judge N172 | Scan |
| 301-1-2 | Tommy McCarthy | 1887-1890 | Old Judge N172 | Scan |
| 301-2-1 | Tommy McCarthy | 1887-1890 | Old Judge N172 | Scan |
| 301-2-2a | Tommy McCarthy | 1887-1890 | Old Judge N172 | Scan |
| 301-2-2b | Tommy McCarthy | 1887-1890 | Old Judge N172 | Scan |
| 301-3-1 | Tommy McCarthy | 1887-1890 | Old Judge N172 | Scan |
| 301-3-2 | Tommy McCarthy | 1887-1890 | Old Judge N172 | Scan |
| 301-4-1 | Tommy McCarthy | 1887-1890 | Old Judge N172 | Scan |
| 301-4-2 | Tommy McCarthy | 1887-1890 | Old Judge N172 | Scan |
| 301-5-1 | Tommy McCarthy | 1887-1890 | Old Judge N172 | Scan |
| 301-5-2 | Tommy McCarthy | 1887-1890 | Old Judge N172 | Scan |
| 301-6 | Tommy McCarthy | 1887-1890 | Old Judge N172 | Scan |
| 301-7a | Tommy McCarthy | 1887-1890 | Old Judge N172 | Scan |
| 301-7b | Tommy McCarthy | 1887-1890 | Old Judge N172 | Scan |
| 301-8 | Tommy McCarthy | 1887-1890 | Old Judge N172 | Scan |
| 301-9a | Tommy McCarthy | 1887-1890 | Old Judge N172 | Scan |
| 301-9b | Tommy McCarthy | 1887-1890 | Old Judge N172 | Scan |
| 301-9c | Tommy McCarthy | 1887-1890 | Old Judge N172 | Scan |
| NNO (13a) | Tommy McCarthy | 1888 | Old Judge Cabinets (N173) | Scan |
| NNO (13b) | Tommy McCarthy | 1888 | Old Judge Cabinets (N173) | Scan |
| 86 | Tommy McCarthy | 1994 | American Archives Origins of Baseball |
