|
Player catagory Player Manager Coach Umpire
|
Record type Birth Death Interment School |
| Name | Class | Record Type | Debut year | Debut date | Date of birth | County | Location |
| Joe Albanese | P | B | 1958 | 07-18-1958 | 6/26/1933 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Andy Allison | PMU | B | 1872 | 05-07-1872 | New York, NY | New York NY | |
| Bill Allison | P | B | 1872 | 05-21-1872 | 7/16/1850 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Pedro Alvarez | P | B | 2010 | 06-16-2010 | 2/6/1987 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Walter Ancker | P | B | 1915 | 09-03-1915 | 4/10/1893 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Alex Arias | P | B | 1992 | 05-12-1992 | 11/20/1967 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Rudy Arroyo | P | B | 1971 | 06-01-1971 | 6/19/1950 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Mike Aviles | P | B | 2008 | 05-29-2008 | 3/13/1981 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Jim Banning | P | B | 1888 | 09-27-1888 | 6/11/1865 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| William Barbeau | P | B | 1905 | 09-27-1905 | 6/10/1882 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Billy Barnie | PMU | B | 1874 | 05-07-1874 | 1/26/1853 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Jose Barrios | P | B | 1982 | 04-23-1982 | 6/26/1957 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Aaron Bates | P | B | 2009 | 07-06-2009 | 3/10/1984 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Tommy Beals | PU | B | 1871 | 07-27-1871 | New York, NY | New York NY | |
| Larry Bearnarth | PC | B | 1963 | 04-16-1963 | 9/11/1941 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Dave Beadle | P | B | 1884 | 06-17-1884 | New York, NY | New York NY | |
| Buck Becannon | PU | B | 1884 | 10-15-1884 | 8/22/1859 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Heinie Beckendorf | P | B | 1909 | 04-16-1909 | 6/15/1884 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Ed Bagley | P | B | 1884 | 05-03-1884 | New York, NY | New York NY | |
| Gene Bagley | P | B | 1886 | 09-11-1886 | 6/7/1861 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Bo Belinsky | P | B | 1962 | 04-18-1962 | 12/7/1936 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Joe Bennett | P | B | 1923 | 07-05-1923 | 7/2/1900 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Moe Berg | PC | B | 1923 | 06-27-1923 | 3/2/1902 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Bob Berman | P | B | 1918 | 06-04-1918 | 1/24/1899 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| William Bestick | P | B | 1872 | 06-20-1872 | New York, NY | New York NY | |
| Dellin Betances | P | B | 2011 | 09-22-2011 | 3/23/1988 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Josh Billings | P | B | 1927 | 08-17-1927 | 9/27/1907 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Dave Birdsall | PU | B | 1871 | 05-05-1871 | 7/16/1838 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Rivington Bisland | P | B | 1912 | 09-13-1912 | 2/17/1890 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Bill Boyd | PMU | B | 1872 | 04-22-1872 | 12/22/1852 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Bill Brady | P | B | 1912 | 07-09-1912 | 8/18/1889 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Alan Brice | P | B | 1961 | 09-22-1961 | 10/1/1937 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Bob Bruce | P | B | 1959 | 09-14-1959 | 5/16/1933 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Charlie Byrne | M | B | 1885 | New York, NY | New York NY | ||
| Pat Callaghan | P | B | 1884 | 05-01-1884 | New York, NY | New York NY | |
| Jim Campanis | P | B | 1966 | 09-20-1966 | 2/9/1944 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Jeimer Candelario | P | B | 2016 | 07-03-2016 | 11/24/1993 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| John Candelaria | P | B | 1975 | 06-08-1975 | 11/6/1953 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Pat Capri | P | B | 1944 | 07-16-1944 | 11/27/1918 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Duke Carmel | P | B | 1959 | 09-10-1959 | 4/23/1937 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Kid Carsey | PU | B | 1891 | 04-08-1891 | 10/22/1872 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Howie Carter | P | B | 1926 | 06-21-1926 | 10/13/1904 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Bob Chlupsa | P | B | 1970 | 07-16-1970 | 9/16/1945 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Darryl Cias | P | B | 1983 | 04-27-1983 | 4/23/1957 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Boileryard Clarke | PU | B | 1893 | 05-01-1893 | 10/18/1868 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Harry Clarke | P | B | 1889 | 08-28-1889 | 1/13/1861 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Tommy Clarke | PC | B | 1909 | 08-26-1909 | 5/9/1888 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Fritz Clausen | P | B | 1892 | 07-23-1892 | 4/26/1869 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Jim Clinton | PU | B | 1872 | 05-18-1872 | 8/10/1850 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Jack Coffey | P | B | 1909 | 06-23-1909 | 1/28/1887 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Alta Cohen | P | B | 1931 | 04-15-1931 | 12/25/1908 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Rocky Colavito | PC | B | 1955 | 09-10-1955 | 8/10/1933 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Phil Cooney | P | B | 1905 | 09-27-1905 | 9/14/1882 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Don Cooper | PMC | B | 1981 | 04-09-1981 | 1/15/1956 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Henry Cotto | P | B | 1984 | 04-05-1984 | 1/5/1961 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Charlie Cushman | MU | B | 1891 | New York, NY | New York NY | ||
| Bob Davis | P | B | 1958 | 07-26-1958 | 9/11/1933 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Jumbo Davis | PU | B | 1884 | 07-27-1884 | 9/5/1861 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Ren Deagle | P | B | 1883 | 05-17-1883 | 6/26/1858 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Mike DeGerick | P | B | 1961 | 09-04-1961 | 4/1/1943 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Garton Del Savio | P | B | 1943 | 04-24-1943 | 11/26/1913 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Travis Demeritte | P | B | 2019 | 08-02-2019 | 9/30/1994 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Jerry Denny | P | B | 1881 | 05-02-1881 | 3/16/1859 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Tony DePhillips | P | B | 1943 | 04-25-1943 | 9/20/1912 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| John Doherty | P | B | 1992 | 04-08-1992 | 6/11/1967 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Tom Dolan | PU | B | 1879 | 09-30-1879 | 1/10/1855 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Herm Doscher | PU | B | 1872 | 09-05-1872 | 12/20/1852 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Bill Dreesen | P | B | 1931 | 05-01-1931 | 7/26/1904 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Andy Dunning | P | B | 1889 | 05-23-1889 | 8/12/1871 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Al Dwight | P | B | 1884 | 06-19-1884 | 1/4/1856 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| George Earnshaw | PC | B | 1928 | 06-03-1928 | 2/15/1900 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Damion Easley | P | B | 1992 | 08-13-1992 | 11/11/1969 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Charlie Ebbets | M | B | 1898 | New York, NY | New York NY | ||
| Bob Emmerich | P | B | 1923 | 09-22-1923 | 8/1/1891 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Charlie Engle | P | B | 1925 | 09-14-1925 | 8/27/1903 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Frank Eustace | P | B | 1896 | 04-16-1896 | 11/7/1873 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Charlie Fallon | P | B | 1905 | 06-30-1905 | 3/7/1881 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Frank Fanovich | P | B | 1949 | 04-25-1949 | 1/11/1923 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Alex Farmer | P | B | 1908 | 09-01-1908 | 5/9/1877 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Harry Feldman | P | B | 1941 | 09-10-1941 | 11/10/1919 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Tom Ferrick | PC | B | 1941 | 04-19-1941 | 1/6/1915 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Bill Finley | P | B | 1886 | 07-12-1886 | 10/4/1863 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| William Fischer | P | B | 1913 | 06-09-1913 | 3/2/1891 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| John Flaherty | P | B | 1992 | 04-12-1992 | 10/21/1967 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Frank Fleet | P | B | 1871 | 10-18-1871 | New York, NY | New York NY | |
| Jose Flores | P | B | 2002 | 09-07-2002 | 6/28/1973 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Davy Force | PU | B | 1871 | 05-05-1871 | 7/27/1849 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Whitey Ford | PC | B | 1950 | 07-01-1950 | 10/21/1928 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Tom Forster | P | B | 1882 | 08-04-1882 | 5/1/1859 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Charlie Fox | PMC | B | 1942 | 09-24-1942 | 10/7/1921 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Joe Foy | P | B | 1966 | 04-13-1966 | 2/21/1943 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Willie Fraser | P | B | 1986 | 09-10-1986 | 5/26/1964 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Bill Froats | P | B | 1955 | 04-22-1955 | 10/20/1930 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Luis Garcia | P | B | 2020 | 08-14-2020 | 5/16/2000 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Al Gardella | P | B | 1945 | 05-17-1945 | 1/11/1918 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Danny Gardella | P | B | 1944 | 05-14-1944 | 2/26/1920 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Alex Gaston | P | B | 1920 | 09-26-1920 | 3/12/1893 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Count Gedney | P | B | 1872 | 04-27-1872 | 5/6/1849 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Lou Gehrig | P | B | 1923 | 06-15-1923 | 6/19/1903 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Dave Gerard | P | B | 1962 | 04-10-1962 | 8/6/1936 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Joe Gingras | P | B | 1915 | 06-18-1915 | 1/10/1893 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Joe Ginsberg | P | B | 1948 | 09-15-1948 | 10/11/1926 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Jonah Goldman | P | B | 1928 | 09-22-1928 | 8/29/1906 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Don Gordon | P | B | 1986 | 04-10-1986 | 10/10/1959 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Tom Gorman | PU | B | 1939 | 09-14-1939 | 3/16/1919 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Tom Gorman | P | B | 1952 | 07-16-1952 | 1/4/1925 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Hank Grampp | P | B | 1927 | 06-21-1927 | 9/28/1903 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Hank Greenberg | P | B | 1930 | 09-14-1930 | 1/1/1911 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Bob Grim | P | B | 1954 | 04-18-1954 | 3/8/1930 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| John Hamill | P | B | 1884 | 05-01-1884 | 12/18/1860 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Frank Hankinson | P | B | 1878 | 05-01-1878 | 4/29/1856 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Lou Hardie | PU | B | 1884 | 05-22-1884 | 8/24/1864 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Mickey Harris | P | B | 1940 | 04-23-1940 | 1/30/1917 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Buddy Hassett | P | B | 1936 | 04-14-1936 | 9/5/1911 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| John Hayes | P | B | 1876 | 09-09-1876 | New York, NY | New York NY | |
| Bill Herring | P | B | 1915 | 06-26-1915 | 10/31/1893 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Herb Hippauf | P | B | 1966 | 04-27-1966 | 5/9/1939 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Charlie Hodes | PU | B | 1871 | 05-08-1871 | New York, NY | New York NY | |
| Fred Hoey | M | B | 1899 | New York, NY | New York NY | ||
| Wally Holborow | P | B | 1944 | 09-27-1944 | 11/30/1913 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Jim Holdsworth | P | B | 1872 | 05-14-1872 | 7/14/1850 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Bill Hollahan | P | B | 1920 | 09-27-1920 | 11/22/1896 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Shorty Howe | PU | B | 1890 | 06-17-1890 | New York, NY | New York NY | |
| Mickey Hughes | P | B | 1888 | 04-22-1888 | 10/25/1866 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Jerry Hurley | P | B | 1901 | 09-22-1901 | New York, NY | New York NY | |
| Jonathan Hurst | P | B | 1992 | 06-09-1992 | 10/20/1966 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Raul Ibanez | P | B | 1996 | 08-01-1996 | 6/2/1972 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Stan Jefferson | P | B | 1986 | 09-07-1986 | 12/4/1962 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Nat Jewett | P | B | 1872 | 07-04-1872 | 12/25/1844 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Miguel Jimenez | P | B | 1993 | 09-12-1993 | 8/19/1969 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Charlie Jones | P | B | 1884 | 06-28-1884 | 10/24/1861 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Tim Jordan | P | B | 1901 | 08-10-1901 | 2/14/1879 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Bill Kalfass | P | B | 1937 | 09-15-1937 | 3/3/1916 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Al Kellett | P | B | 1923 | 06-29-1923 | 10/30/1901 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Duke Kelleher | P | B | 1916 | 08-18-1916 | 9/30/1893 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Bill Kelly | P | B | 1871 | 05-04-1871 | New York, NY | New York NY | |
| Joe Kelly | P | B | 1926 | 04-13-1926 | 4/23/1900 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Kick Kelly | PM | B | 1879 | 05-01-1879 | 10/31/1856 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Jim Kennedy | M | B | 1890 | New York, NY | New York NY | ||
| William Kinsler | P | B | 1893 | 06-08-1893 | 11/9/1867 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Chris Kitsos | P | B | 1954 | 04-21-1954 | 2/11/1928 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Ed Kranepool | P | B | 1962 | 09-22-1962 | 11/8/1944 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Pete Lamer | P | B | 1902 | 09-10-1902 | 12/27/1873 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Billy Lauder | PC | B | 1898 | 06-25-1898 | 2/23/1874 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Fred Lear | P | B | 1915 | 06-07-1915 | 4/7/1894 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Al Lefevre | P | B | 1920 | 06-28-1920 | 9/16/1898 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Mike Lehane | P | B | 1890 | 04-17-1890 | 4/15/1865 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Lou Limmer | P | B | 1951 | 04-22-1951 | 3/10/1925 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Ernie Lindemann | P | B | 1907 | 06-28-1907 | 6/10/1883 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Eddie Lopat | PMC | B | 1944 | 04-30-1944 | 6/21/1918 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Bill Loughran | P | B | 1884 | 06-06-1884 | New York, NY | New York NY | |
| Willie Lozado | P | B | 1984 | 07-16-1984 | 5/12/1959 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Jack Lynch | PU | B | 1881 | 05-02-1881 | 2/5/1857 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Harvey MacDonald | P | B | 1928 | 06-12-1928 | 5/18/1898 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Jim Maler | P | B | 1981 | 09-03-1981 | 8/16/1958 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Dave Martinez | PC | B | 1986 | 06-15-1986 | 9/26/1964 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Edgar Martinez | P | B | 1987 | 09-12-1987 | 1/2/1963 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Phonney Martin | PMU | B | 1872 | 04-26-1872 | 8/4/1845 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Julius Matos | P | B | 2002 | 05-31-2002 | 12/12/1974 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Lee Mazzilli | PMC | B | 1976 | 09-07-1976 | 3/25/1955 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Frank McCarton | P | B | 1872 | 04-26-1872 | 10/6/1854 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Frank McCormick | PC | B | 1934 | 09-11-1934 | 6/9/1911 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Danny McDevitt | P | B | 1957 | 06-17-1957 | 11/18/1932 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Dan McGee | P | B | 1934 | 07-14-1934 | 9/29/1911 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Hugh McQuillan | P | B | 1918 | 07-26-1918 | 9/15/1895 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Charlie Meara | P | B | 1914 | 06-01-1914 | 4/16/1891 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Walt Meinert | P | B | 1913 | 09-06-1913 | 12/11/1890 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Dutch Mele | P | B | 1937 | 09-14-1937 | 1/11/1915 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Mike Meola | P | B | 1933 | 04-24-1933 | 10/19/1905 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Hack Miller | P | B | 1916 | 09-22-1916 | 1/1/1894 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Izzy Molina | P | B | 1996 | 08-15-1996 | 6/3/1971 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Felix Moses | M | B | 1884 | New York, NY | New York NY | ||
| Johnny Murphy | PC | B | 1932 | 05-19-1932 | 7/14/1908 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Tony Murphy | P | B | 1884 | 10-15-1884 | New York, NY | New York NY | |
| Walter Murphy | P | B | 1931 | 04-19-1931 | 9/27/1907 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Sam Nahem | P | B | 1938 | 10-02-1938 | 10/19/1915 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Bots Nekola | P | B | 1929 | 07-19-1929 | 12/10/1906 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Charlie Niebergall | P | B | 1921 | 06-17-1921 | 5/23/1899 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| James Norwood | P | B | 2018 | 07-11-2018 | 12/24/1993 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Rafael Novoa | P | B | 1990 | 07-31-1990 | 10/26/1967 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| John O'Neill | P | B | 1899 | 09-06-1899 | New York, NY | New York NY | |
| Tom O'Rourke | P | B | 1887 | 05-11-1887 | New York, NY | New York NY | |
| Walter Ockey | P | B | 1944 | 05-03-1944 | 1/4/1920 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Rube Oldring | P | B | 1905 | 10-02-1905 | 5/30/1884 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Dave Orr | PMU | B | 1883 | 05-17-1883 | 9/29/1859 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Bill Oster | P | B | 1954 | 08-23-1954 | 1/2/1933 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Adam Ottavino | P | B | 2010 | 05-29-2010 | 11/22/1985 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Billy Ott | P | B | 1962 | 09-04-1962 | 11/23/1940 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Charlie Pabor | PMU | B | 1871 | 05-04-1871 | 9/24/1846 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Jim Palmer | P | B | 1965 | 04-17-1965 | 10/15/1945 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Tom Patterson | PU | B | 1871 | 05-18-1871 | New York, NY | New York NY | |
| Pedro Payano | P | B | 2019 | 07-06-2019 | 9/27/1994 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Monte Pfeffer | P | B | 1913 | 09-29-1913 | 10/8/1891 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Kewpie Pennington | P | B | 1917 | 04-14-1917 | 9/24/1896 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Nealy Phelps | PU | B | 1871 | 07-01-1871 | 11/19/1840 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Val Picinich | PC | B | 1916 | 07-25-1916 | 9/8/1896 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Gracie Pierce | PU | B | 1882 | 05-02-1882 | New York, NY | New York NY | |
| Sandy Piez | P | B | 1914 | 04-17-1914 | 10/13/1889 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Lip Pike | PMU | B | 1871 | 05-09-1871 | 5/25/1845 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Jake Pitler | PC | B | 1917 | 05-30-1917 | 4/22/1894 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Arnie Portocarrero | P | B | 1954 | 04-18-1954 | 7/5/1931 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Jim Powers | P | B | 1890 | 04-18-1890 | New York, NY | New York NY | |
| Phil Powers | PU | B | 1878 | 08-31-1878 | 7/26/1854 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Jim Price | M | B | 1884 | New York, NY | New York NY | ||
| Jimmie Reese | PC | B | 1930 | 04-19-1930 | 10/1/1901 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Jim Reilly | P | B | 1885 | 06-08-1885 | New York, NY | New York NY | |
| Xavier Rescigno | P | B | 1943 | 04-22-1943 | 10/13/1912 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Otto Rettig | P | B | 1922 | 07-19-1922 | 1/29/1894 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Harry Riconda | P | B | 1923 | 04-19-1923 | 5/17/1897 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Jim Rivera | P | B | 1952 | 04-15-1952 | 7/22/1921 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Alex Rodriguez | P | B | 1994 | 07-08-1994 | 7/27/1975 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| John Rodriguez | P | B | 2005 | 07-18-2005 | 1/20/1978 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Victor Rodriguez | P | B | 1984 | 09-05-1984 | 7/14/1961 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| James Roseman | PM | B | 1882 | 05-01-1882 | 7/4/1856 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Max Rosenfeld | P | B | 1931 | 04-21-1931 | 12/23/1902 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Dick Rudolph | PMC | B | 1910 | 09-30-1910 | 8/25/1887 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Joe Rullo | P | B | 1943 | 09-22-1943 | 6/16/1916 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Al Schacht | PC | B | 1919 | 09-18-1919 | 11/11/1892 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Heinie Scheer | P | B | 1922 | 04-20-1922 | 7/31/1900 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Ted Scheffler | P | B | 1888 | 08-07-1888 | 4/5/1864 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Richie Scheinblum | P | B | 1965 | 09-01-1965 | 11/5/1942 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| George Seward | PU | B | 1875 | 05-19-1875 | New York, NY | New York NY | |
| Norm Sherry | PMC | B | 1959 | 04-12-1959 | 7/16/1931 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Fred Siefke | P | B | 1890 | 05-02-1890 | 3/5/1870 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Walter Signer | P | B | 1943 | 09-18-1943 | 10/12/1910 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Joe Simmons | PMU | B | 1871 | 05-08-1871 | 6/13/1845 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Ken Singleton | P | B | 1970 | 06-24-1970 | 6/10/1947 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Aleck Smith | P | B | 1897 | 04-23-1897 | New York, NY | New York NY | |
| John Smith | P | B | 1882 | 05-01-1882 | New York, NY | New York NY | |
| Joe Smith | P | B | 1913 | 07-07-1913 | 12/29/1893 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Mose Solomon | P | B | 1923 | 09-30-1923 | 12/8/1900 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Harry Spence | M | B | 1888 | New York, NY | New York NY | ||
| Joe Start | PM | B | 1871 | 05-18-1871 | 10/14/1842 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Snuffy Stirnweiss | P | B | 1943 | 04-22-1943 | 10/26/1918 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Tom Sullivan | P | B | 1884 | 09-27-1884 | 3/1/1860 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Bill Swarback | P | B | 1887 | 07-09-1887 | 8/1/1867 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Bill Swanson | P | B | 1914 | 09-02-1914 | 10/12/1888 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Rooney Sweeney | P | B | 1883 | 07-25-1883 | 11/1/1858 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Tony Tarasco | P | B | 1993 | 04-30-1993 | 12/9/1970 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Don Taussig | P | B | 1958 | 04-23-1958 | 2/19/1932 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Nick Testa | PC | B | 1958 | 04-23-1958 | 6/29/1928 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Rich Thompson | P | B | 1985 | 04-28-1985 | 11/1/1958 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| John Tilley | P | B | 1882 | 08-23-1882 | New York, NY | New York NY | |
| Specs Toporcer | P | B | 1921 | 04-13-1921 | 2/9/1899 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Dasher Troy | P | B | 1881 | 08-23-1881 | 5/8/1856 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Eddie Turchin | P | B | 1943 | 05-09-1943 | 2/10/1917 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Scott Ullger | PMC | B | 1983 | 04-17-1983 | 6/10/1955 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Vince Ventura | P | B | 1945 | 05-08-1945 | 4/18/1917 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Heinie Wagner | PMC | B | 1902 | 07-01-1902 | 9/23/1880 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Joe Wagner | P | B | 1915 | 04-14-1915 | 4/24/1889 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Jack Warner | PU | B | 1895 | 04-23-1895 | 8/15/1872 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Hal Warnock | P | B | 1935 | 09-02-1935 | 1/6/1912 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Fred Waterman | PMU | B | 1871 | 05-05-1871 | New York, NY | New York NY | |
| Lew Wendell | P | B | 1915 | 06-10-1915 | 3/22/1892 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Jack White | P | B | 1927 | 06-22-1927 | 8/31/1905 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Gus Williams | P | B | 1890 | 04-18-1890 | New York, NY | New York NY | |
| Bobby Wine | PMC | B | 1960 | 09-20-1960 | 9/17/1938 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Favel Wordsworth | P | B | 1873 | 04-28-1873 | New York, NY | New York NY | |
| Al Wright | M | B | 1876 | New York, NY | New York NY | ||
| George Wright | PM | B | 1871 | 05-05-1871 | 1/28/1847 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Sam Wright | P | B | 1875 | 04-19-1875 | 11/25/1848 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Sal Yvars | P | B | 1947 | 09-27-1947 | 2/20/1924 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Heinie Zimmerman | P | B | 1907 | 09-08-1907 | 2/9/1887 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Abraham Gilbert - U - Mills | U | B | 1877 | 09-08-1907 | 2/9/1887 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Emile de Gall - U - Fountain | U | B | 1879 | 09-08-1907 | 2/9/1887 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Joseph - U - Donnegan | U | B | 1881 | 09-08-1907 | 2/9/1887 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| William Henry - U - Becannon | U | B | 1883 | 09-08-1907 | 2/9/1887 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| John M. - U - Connolly | U | B | 1884 | 09-08-1907 | 2/9/1887 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| William H. - U - Jordan | U | B | 1884 | 09-08-1907 | 2/9/1887 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| William H. - U - Quinn | U | B | 1884 | 09-08-1907 | 2/9/1887 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Henry V. - U - Fountain | U | B | 1888 | 09-08-1907 | 2/9/1887 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| August - U - Moran | U | B | 1903 | 09-08-1907 | 2/9/1887 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Jacob Paul - U - Steinberg | U | B | 1909 | 09-08-1907 | 2/9/1887 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| William Jeremiah - U - Byron | U | B | 1913 | 09-08-1907 | 2/9/1887 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Albert D. - U - Stark | U | B | 1928 | 09-08-1907 | 2/9/1887 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Edward Paul - U - Runge | U | B | 1954 | 09-08-1907 | 2/9/1887 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Melvin James - U - Steiner | U | B | 1961 | 09-08-1907 | 2/9/1887 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| George Patrick - U - Maloney | U | B | 1969 | 09-08-1907 | 2/9/1887 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Henry Charles - U - Morgenweck | U | B | 1970 | 09-08-1907 | 2/9/1887 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| John F. - U - Mackin | U | B | 1979 | 09-08-1907 | 2/9/1887 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Harold L. - U - Siroka | U | B | 1979 | 09-08-1907 | 2/9/1887 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Rolando Jesus - C - Dearmas | C | B | 1995 | 09-08-1907 | 2/9/1887 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| Joseph M. - C - Rigoli | C | B | 1996 | 09-08-1907 | 2/9/1887 | New York, NY | New York NY |
| William Joseph - C - Evers | C | B | 2006 | 09-08-1907 | 2/9/1887 | New York, NY | New York NY |