| Name | BBrefID | Year | Span | Games | Team | League |
Location |
| Abel | | 1867 | | 8 g.
| Philadelphia West Philadelphia | Independent |
Philadelphia, PA |
| George Bechtel | bechte001geo | 1867 | | 4 g.
| Philadelphia West Philadelphia | Independent |
Philadelphia, PA |
| Clinton | | 1867 | | 7 g.
| Philadelphia West Philadelphia | Independent |
Philadelphia, PA |
| Ned Cuthbert | cuthbe001ned | 1867 | | 4 g.
| Philadelphia West Philadelphia | Independent |
Philadelphia, PA |
| Dorsey | | 1867 | | 7 g.
| Philadelphia West Philadelphia | Independent |
Philadelphia, PA |
| Cherokee Fisher | fisher001che | 1867 | | 10 g.
| Philadelphia West Philadelphia | Independent |
Philadelphia, PA |
| Hellings | hellin001--- | 1867 | +9/26+ |
| Philadelphia West Philadelphia | Independent |
Philadelphia, PA |
| Maguire | | 1867 | | 8 g.
| Philadelphia West Philadelphia | Independent |
Philadelphia, PA |
| S. Myers | | 1867 | | 8 g.
| Philadelphia West Philadelphia | Independent |
Philadelphia, PA |
| E. Osterheldt | | 1867 | | 11 g.
| Philadelphia West Philadelphia | Independent |
Philadelphia, PA |
| William Osterheldt | | 1867 | | 4 g.
| Philadelphia West Philadelphia | Independent |
Philadelphia, PA |
| Charley Weaver | | 1867 | | 10 g.
| Philadelphia West Philadelphia | Independent |
Philadelphia, PA |
| J. Weaver | | 1867 | | 4 g.
| Philadelphia West Philadelphia | Independent |
Philadelphia, PA |