| Name | BBrefID | Year | Span | Games | Team | League |
Location |
| Bennett | bennet023--- | 1898 | +6/15- |
| Oil City Oilers/Dunkirk-Fredonia | Iron and Oil League |
Oil City, PA |
| Burke | | 1898 | +6/22-6/30+ |
| Oil City Oilers/Dunkirk-Fredonia | Iron and Oil League |
Fredonia, NY |
| Frank Campbell | campbe001fra | 1898 | |
| Oil City Oilers/Dunkirk-Fredonia | Iron and Oil League |
Oil City, PA |
| Frank Chilcott | chilco001fra | 1898 | +6/29-6/30+ |
| Oil City Oilers/Dunkirk-Fredonia | Iron and Oil League |
Dunkirk, NY |
| Harry Clayton | clayto001har | 1898 | +6/15- |
| Oil City Oilers/Dunkirk-Fredonia | Iron and Oil League |
Oil City, PA |
| Tom Coyne | coyne-001tom | 1898 | |
| Oil City Oilers/Dunkirk-Fredonia | Iron and Oil League |
Oil City, PA |
| Eddie Gilligan | gillig001edw | 1898 | |
| Oil City Oilers/Dunkirk-Fredonia | Iron and Oil League |
Fredonia, NY |
| Frank Gunther | gunthe001fra | 1898 | |
| Oil City Oilers/Dunkirk-Fredonia | Iron and Oil League |
Oil City, PA |
| Hall | | 1898 | 6/20-7/1+ |
| Oil City Oilers/Dunkirk-Fredonia | Iron and Oil League |
Dunkirk, NY |
| Guy Hecker | hecker001guy | 1898 | 5/13-6/17 |
| Oil City Oilers/Dunkirk-Fredonia | Iron and Oil League |
Oil City, PA |
| Guy Hecker | hecker001guy | 1898 | 6/18-7/14 |
| Oil City Oilers/Dunkirk-Fredonia | Iron and Oil League |
Fredonia, NY |
| Hewitt | | 1898 | |
| Oil City Oilers/Dunkirk-Fredonia | Iron and Oil League |
Dunkirk, NY |
| Will Hodgkinson | hodgki001wil | 1898 | |
| Oil City Oilers/Dunkirk-Fredonia | Iron and Oil League |
Oil City, PA |
| A.L. Johnson | johnso006a-- | 1898 | |
| Oil City Oilers/Dunkirk-Fredonia | Iron and Oil League |
Oil City, PA |
| John Kelly | kelly-013joh | 1898 | 5/13-6/3+ |
| Oil City Oilers/Dunkirk-Fredonia | Iron and Oil League |
Oil City, PA |
| Kelly | kelly-078--- | 1898 | +6/21+ |
| Oil City Oilers/Dunkirk-Fredonia | Iron and Oil League |
Oil City, PA |
| Leighman | | 1898 | |
| Oil City Oilers/Dunkirk-Fredonia | Iron and Oil League |
Dunkirk, NY |
| Jim Leighton | leight001jam | 1898 | 5/13-6/15+ |
| Oil City Oilers/Dunkirk-Fredonia | Iron and Oil League |
Oil City, PA |
| Jim Leighton | leight001jam | 1898 | 6/20-7/7+ |
| Oil City Oilers/Dunkirk-Fredonia | Iron and Oil League |
Fredonia, NY |
| A.D. Lyons | lyons-001a-- | 1898 | |
| Oil City Oilers/Dunkirk-Fredonia | Iron and Oil League |
Oil City, PA |
| A.D. Lyons | lyons-001a-- | 1898 | +6/22+ |
| Oil City Oilers/Dunkirk-Fredonia | Iron and Oil League |
Fredonia, NY |
| Charles McGill | mcgill002cha | 1898 | |
| Oil City Oilers/Dunkirk-Fredonia | Iron and Oil League |
Oil City, PA |
| Charles Miller | miller019cha | 1898 | |
| Oil City Oilers/Dunkirk-Fredonia | Iron and Oil League |
Oil City, PA |
| Ed Quinn | quinn-001ed- | 1898 | +5/25+ |
| Oil City Oilers/Dunkirk-Fredonia | Iron and Oil League |
Oil City, PA |
| Danny Shea | shea--001dan | 1898 | |
| Oil City Oilers/Dunkirk-Fredonia | Iron and Oil League |
Oil City, PA |
| Fred Shires | shires001fre | 1898 | +5/28-7/11+ |
| Oil City Oilers/Dunkirk-Fredonia | Iron and Oil League |
Oil City, PA |
| Arthur Swaim | swaim-001art | 1898 | +5/14-6/15+ |
| Oil City Oilers/Dunkirk-Fredonia | Iron and Oil League |
Oil City, PA |
| Arthur Swaim | swaim-001art | 1898 | +6/21-6/29+ |
| Oil City Oilers/Dunkirk-Fredonia | Iron and Oil League |
Fredonia, NY |
| Williams | willia250--- | 1898 | +6/3-6/6+ |
| Oil City Oilers/Dunkirk-Fredonia | Iron and Oil League |
Oil City, PA |