Harry Staley

Born: November 3, 1866
Died:
MLB Debut: June,23, 1888
Goto Baseball-Reference.com for Harry Staley


Scan not available

Harry Staley was considered one of the best pitchers in the Western Association before even throwing a pitch in a game, and there was speculation that he would be transferred to the Browns from the start of the season. He was the Whites Opening Day starter and star of the game, allowing only a single unearned run while hitting a double and a triple. He made 19 more starts for the Whites, finishing with a record of 9-11. His ERA was 1.76, and he struck out 138 batters in 179 innings, both in the top ten in the league. He also played several games in the outfielder for the Whites towards the end of ther final roadtrip. He was sold with Jake Beckley to Pittsburgh for $4500 on June 19, the last day of the Whites' road final trip. He lost to the Maroons by a score of 8-5 that day, surrendering 14 hits and 7 earned runs in his final start.

Staley started his baseball career playing semi-pro baseball in Illinois. He played for the Springfield Reds in 1886, and in 1887 signed with Decatur. While with Decatur, he was consistantly striking out more than 10 batters per game. It was reported that he struck out 'more than twenty' pitching against Mt. Zion in July of 1887 (Decatur Herald, July 3, 1887). Although he was pursued by several higher level clubs during the season, including Indianapolis in the National League, he choose to stay in Decatur until the club folded in September, at which point he transferred to the Blomington team in the same league. After the season ended, he was signed by Tom Loftus to pitch for the Whites.

Staley made his National League debut on June 23 with 3 innings in relief in a 12-1 loss to Chicago; he allowed just one run, in his first inning pitched in the majors. He made his first start a week later on June 30, with a 6-4 win over Chicago. His best game of the season was a one-hitter against Indianapolis in July, which Pitsburgh won 8-0. He finished the season with a 12-12 record, a 2.69 ERA and 89 strikeouts in 207.1 innings. The next season with Pittsburgh he compiled a 21-26 record. He pitched in 49 games for Pittsburgh in 1889, starting 47 of them, both tops on the club. His ERA of 3.51 was sixth best in the league, his 159 strikeouts ranked third, and his 420 innings was the second most in the league (behind John Clarkson, who pitched 620 innings in 73 games, 72 starts). He jumped to Pittsburgh in the Players League in 1890, where he was one of the top pitchers. His ERA of 3.29 was second in the league behind Silver King. He was in the top ten in strikeouts and led the league in WHIP (1.213). Despite this, he was only 21-25 for a Pittsburgh club that finished at 60-68 in sixth place.

After the Players League folded, Staley returned to Pittsburgh in the National League in 1891. He was 4-5 with them when he was released to Boston in late May. He rebounded to finish at 20-8 with Boston as they won the National League pennant with an 87-51 record. The next season he finished 22-10 with a 3.30 ERA as the #3 starter on a team that won 104 games and its second consecutive title. In 1893, the pitching distance increased. Staley still won 18 games, but his strikeouts dropped for the thrid straight season, his WHIP increased from 1.2 to 1.6, and his ERA jumped from 3.03 to 5.13. In 1894, his final season with Boston, he went 12-10 and it was clear he was no longer the top starter he had been just a few years prior. In 1891, prior to his being released to Boston, the Philadelphia club had passed on a chance to claim him due to his drinking. By the end of the 1894 season, that habit had taken its toll; he weighed over 217 pounds by one report. He was also unhappy with his pay in Boston, which went down each year after his first season. In January of 1895, he signed with the Browns, claiming his last contract with Boston did not include the usual reserve clause; Boston did not contest the signing.

Staley returned to St. Louis in 1895 with hopes on both sides that he could revive his career. His weight was down to 170 pounds, and he was working himself back into condition in the off-season. Hope didn't turn into success, and he was 6-13 for the Browns before being released August 3. St. Louis was 28-57 at the time, so Staley wasn't the only player underperforming on the club. The Browns had three managers that season as they finished 11th in the 12 team National League. Their first manager, Al Buckenberger, signed Staley to play for his new club, Wheeling, after Staley was released. Staley played four more seasons in he minors, finishing his career in 1899 at age 32. He was given a tryout with Baltimore in 1901, but failed to make the club. His career was over. But for at least a few years, he was one of the top pitchers in baseball, fulfilling the promise he showed in 1888.

After leaving baseball, Staley stayed in Pittsburgh before moving to Battle Creek, Michigan, where he worked for Post cereal. (His sister was married to one of the members of the Post family.) He died in 1910 of complications from stomach surgery.



Major League record for Harry Staley

Batting stats
Year   Team              Pos            Age    G   AB    R    H   2B   3B   HR  RBI   BB    K   SB   CS     AVG    OBP    SLG
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1888   Pit-N             P               21   25   85    6   11    1    0    0    1    1   18    2        0.129  0.149  0.141
1889   Pit-N             P-OF            22   51  186   11   30    3    1    0    8    4   40    1        0.161  0.179  0.188
1890   Pit-P             P-OF            23   48  168   25   35    3    2    1   25   13   16    0        0.208  0.269  0.268
1891   Pit-N                             24    9   31    4    7    0    1    0    3    3    4    0        0.226  0.294  0.290
1891   Bos-N                             24   31  102    7   17    4    0    1   16    8   17    0        0.167  0.234  0.235
1892   Bos-N             P-OF            25   38  122    9   16    2    0    1    9    9   38    2        0.131  0.191  0.172
1893   Bos-N             P               26   36  113   13   30    5    0    2   21   10   17    1        0.265  0.325  0.363
1894   Bos-N             P-OF            27   28   85   12   20    2    1    2   25   13    9    0        0.235  0.343  0.353
1895   StL-N             P               28   23   67    4    9    0    2    0    1    4    1    1        0.134  0.183  0.194
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Totals (8 yrs)                               289  959   91  175   20    7    7  109   65  160    7    0   0.182  0.237  0.240


Pitching stats
Year   Team              Pos            Age    W    L     ERA    G   GS   CG   SH    S      IP     R   ER    H   HR   BB    K
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1888   Pit-N             P               21   12   12    2.69   25   24   24    2    0   207.1   104   62  185    6   53   89
1889   Pit-N             P               22   21   26    3.51   49   47   46    1    1   420.0   254  164  433   11  116  159
1890   Pit-P             P               23   21   25    3.29   47   47   45    3    0   396.2   258  145  404    6   77  150
1891   Pit-N             P               24    4    5    2.89    9    7    6    0    0    71.2    49   23   77    4   11   25
1891   Bos-N             P               24   20    8    2.50   31   30   26    1    0   252.1   111   70  236   12   69  114
1892   Bos-N             P               25   22   10    3.03   37   35   31    3    0   299.2   144  101  273   10   97   93
1893   Bos-N             P               26   18   10    5.13   36   31   23    0    0   263.0   224  150  344   22   81   61
1894   Bos-N             P               27   12   10    6.81   27   21   18    0    1   208.2   204  158  305   15   61   32
1895   StL-N             P               28    6   13    5.22   23   16   13    0    0   158.2   136   92  223    8   39   28
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Totals (8 yrs)                               136  119    3.81  284  258  232   10    2  2275.2  1484  965 2480   94  604  751


Stats with the St. Louis Whites

Batting stats
Year Team Pos Age G AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI BB K SB CS AVG OBP SLG ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1888 STW 21 23 84 7 16 5 1 0 1 0.191 0.274 Pitching stats
Year Team Pos Age W L ERA G GS CG SH S IP R H HR BB K ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 1888 STW P 21 9 11 1.76 20 20 20 1 179.0 93 137 57 130

Spring stats for the Whites

Batting stats
  Date       Opponent      Pos.    AB    R   BH   2B   3B   HR	SB   BB    K
3/25/1888    Browns          p      3    0    1                  0         1
3/27/1888    Browns          p      3    0    0                  0
3/28/1888    Browns          p      3    0    1                  0
3/29/1888    Browns          p      3    1    2                  0
 4/1/1888    Prickly Ash     p      4    2    2         1        0
 4/8/1888    Browns          p      3    0    2                  0
4/12/1888    Kansas City     p      3    0    2
4/16/1888    Bloomington     p      4    2    2    1             1
4/19/1888    Peoria          p      4    0    1
4/22/1888    Davenport       p      3    0    0                  0
4/25/1888    Dubuque         p      4    2    0                  0
Totals (11 G)                      37    7   13    1    1    0   1    0    1
0 putouts, 93 assists and 14 errors
(Note walks allowed were counted as errors for the pitcher)

Pitching stats
  Date       Opponent      Pos.    IP    R   ER    H   BB    K  HBP   WP
3/25/1888    Browns          p      4    3    2    6    0    1    0
3/27/1888    Browns          p      4    3    1    5    1    3    0
3/28/1888    Browns          p      4    4    2    6    1    1    0    0
3/29/1888    Browns          p      5    5    2    5    1    4    1
 4/1/1888    Prickly Ash     p      9    1    0    1    1   16    2
 4/8/1888    Browns          p      9   10    7   10    2    8    0    0
4/12/1888    Kansas City     p      9    4    0    9    2   16    0    0
4/16/1888    Bloomington     p      9    0    0    3    0   18    0    0
4/19/1888    Peoria          p      9    3    2    6    1    0    0    0
4/22/1888    Davenport       p      9    3    1    6    4   13    1
4/25/1888    Dubuque         p      9    4    4    9    0   10    0    0
Totals (11 G)                      80   40   21   66   13   70    4    0